DC Comics Reboot: Is the Justice League too White?; Superman Misplaces Vital Item

The reboot in question is 2011’s New 52.  A lot has changed since then, but a lot of this still holds up.  From 2011: 

I’m just going to go ahead and be a nerd here for a few minutes.  DC Comics is renumbering three-quarters of their titles with 52 new Issue #1’s staggered weekly beginning August 31.  That’s essentially a reboot, right?  DC honchos are calling it a new point of entry for a new generation of readers, which makes sense given the massive platforms offered by the popularity of superhero movies and merchandising.

Fine. Actually, more than fine.  I think it’s a great idea. A lot of fanboys think it’s long overdue after the almost-reboots of the last few years, but I think the timing is perfect.  I think it’s great and I look forward to it.  It might get me to start subscribing to a few regular titles again, which would be a lot of fun (especially since I have a vintage grocery store comics rack that I can’t fit my bagged and boarded 90’s books in). What I’m not so sure about is the new Justice League roster (Batman, Superman, Wonder Woman, Flash, Green Lantern Hal Jordan, Aquaman, and … Cyborg?)

I’m always of the opinion that the Justice League should be Superman, Batman, The Flash, Wonder Woman, a Green Lantern, and Aquaman.  I left out Green Arrow.  Maybe I shouldn’t have.  Is he iconic? Green Arrow is on the bubble, like the letter y.  He’s a legacy character with classic runs in the 70s, and he’s the team’s resident dissident/progressive.  He’s the League’s only bow-and-arrow guy, so there’s that.  But he’s not an archetype like the Big Three, and he doesn’t stand in for great elemental and cosmic forces (Aquaman, Flash, Green Lantern).  The same’s true for Cyborg, and so I’m conflicted.  Nothing against Vic, but neither his history nor his skill-set seem to bring something essential, or quintessential, to the team.

I know without Vic, the team is all-white, and I don’t think that’s acceptable.  Who’s the most iconic of all the non-white characters in the DCU?  John Stewart as the Green Lantern?  Absolutely.  He was the best character on the the animated Justice League series not named Batman (sorry, John, but Bats will always be my favorite), and, truth be told, he carried the show and the team.  Justice League established him in popular media as a quintessential character to the JL mythos, and it wasn’t because of his green ring.  It was because of how awesome, conflicted, and noble he was.  What does Hal Jordan really bring to the table? I know, I know, he’s the Silver Age original, but while he was away, John Stewart became the definitive Green Lantern for me, even as Wally West became the Flash.  Sorry, but that’s just how I see it.  Somewhere, someone is saying “what about Kyle Rayner?”  Exactly.  Loved him.  Haven’t thought about him in years.

I’d bump Hal and Cyborg and sign John up in a heartbeat, if he’d take the job.  If DC is also hoping to skew younger with the Cyborg character (he’s historically been cast as younger than the DCU’s banner heroes), what about Static?  Isn’t his full inclusion in the top narratives of the DCU long overdue?  Wouldn’t putting Static in the JLA add some much-needed youth and also be a more-than-fitting tribute to the late Dwayne McDuffie?  No one else pictured above has Static’s elemental kind of powers.  There’s a fast guy, a strong girl, a strong guy, a dark avenger guy, a mystical space military guy, a water guy.  Where’s the electric guy?  Static to the Justice League the second I’m in the door at Editorial. (Also, Pete Rose to the Hall of Fame).

All of this still leaves us with a relatively undiverse grouping, but it’s a step in the right direction.  Where’s Martian Manhunter, by the way?  I know he’s dead in current continuity, and I’m guessing that he’ll appear later in the series like he did way back when in the original. Speaking of which, I know that Supes and Batman weren’t part of the old league back in the day, but whatever. I’m writing about comic books so I get to say that.

On to my second issue.  It has to do with costumes.  Wonder Woman’s change is long overdue, but they should have kept some yellow.  Black threads on a color palette that doesn’t historically have them are gimmicky in baseball and gimmicky in comics. Aquaman looks great, which is sometimes hard for Aquaman to do. This look honors his history even as the military collar recalls his finest hours as my harpoon-handed beard-twin.  (His current incarnation on Batman: The Brave and The Bold is brilliant and my undeniable favorite).  The Flash has those weird piping lines on his cowl, which is to be expected with these kind of reboots. If you look closely, Batman probably has them, too, and his gauntlets are more modular and armor-like.  Fine, though I like a cleaner cowl for Batman. Flash’s chin thing is meant to make his ensemble look younger, hipper.  Fine.

But sweet Siegel and Shuster, where on Krypton are Superman’s red briefs?  What’s with the bishop/general collar?  I only just now noticed the blue on blue gauntlet piping and red sleeve trim.  Is that a red belt?  I can only imagine what his boots look like.  This feels a lot like the future version of Superman that Connor Kent/Superboy became a while back in Teen Titans.  I thought then that the evolution of this look might work over time, but this seems so sudden, so…drastic.   This is Superman we’re talking about.  I know he’s been changed in varying degrees over the years, but the late Golden Age and Silver Age look has been kept largely intact until now.  The lack of briefs is shocking, but the collar bugs me most.  It looks way too Zod for Kal.  And now that I’ve lost most of my regular readers, I bid you a fond “till next time!”

9 thoughts on “DC Comics Reboot: Is the Justice League too White?; Superman Misplaces Vital Item

  1. I too am having difficulty seeing Superman without the red briefs. Course, I’ll probably still check out the reboot. The world needs its superheroes, no matter what they’re wearing. Thanks for spreading the word.

  2. I almost think that if your going to do an overhaul, go all the way and revamp to the point of re imagining. These characters just look younger, not better.

    1. They definitely look younger, not better. Good way to put it. I think if they reimagined the characters too much, it might be too big a departure. Special runs like “Just Imagine….Stan Lee Presents” (his take on the DCU) are awesome, as are Elseworlds books other reimaginings. Marvel’s Ultimate Universe is a good example of rebooting/reimagining while still publishing the old continuities. This is a pretty big move for DC…I’m interested to see how it shakes out.

  3. Moar Green Arrow/Static (probably Static; that’s a format that could do really well in today’s generation), less Aquaman. Aquaman is a joke, and every young reader that DC is trying to get to start reading again knows it. Also, did Wonderwoman get implants? I’m also having some reservations with Green Lantern and Flash looking beefier than Superman…

    All in all, I’m kind of excited/nervous for the reboot. One thing I DON’T like: Thomas Wayne survives the attack, not Bruce. I just don’t know how I feel about that. It feels like saying “We re-booted the Bible, and now Moses is the son of God, not Jesus”. That one was one too far for me, which sucks because I was pumped for a Batman reboot (not that it needed it, but just something new).

    Also, being the Batman nerd you are: Did you read Kevin Smith’s Cacophony arc and The Widening Gyre arc? So good.

    1. how about pairing GA and Hal up in their own book again? Make them all kinds of progressive again, too…they can fight banks and corporations and corrupt regimes. Then put John Stewart and Static on JLA. Aquaman has it tough…which is why you have to go big (Brave and the Bold) or go home.

      Are you telling me that the reason Batman alone doesn’t look like a member of Teen Titans in the image above is because he’s now Thomas Wayne??? Fffwhat? I have some serious Googling to do.

      Haven’t read Smith on Bats, but I will. Thanks for the head’s up!

  4. Cacophony and Widening Gyre were the first comics I read, reading them only as a K Smith fanboy. I’ve now read his Green Hornet arc, have read every Walking Dead, and am working on getting caught up in The Boys.

  5. I think they gave him a red belt instead of the briefs to give him more dignity… even though the former version is more of an icon.

  6. Okay, you said that Aquaman isn’t iconic. Why? Aquaman is far more iconic than Green Lantern and Flash. He’s probably more iconic than Wonder Woman too.

Join the discussion!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.