Even if you don’t live in Allentown or the Lehigh Valley, if you’re interested in infrastructure, urban renewal, and stopping suburban sprawl (let’s call it “mall creep”), this post is for you.
As you might know, the former Philadelphia Phantoms are coming to Allentown. The Phantoms are the top-level developmental affiliate of the Philadelphia Flyers, and their new arena is being built downtown as the centerpiece of what will ultimately be at least a $600 million dollar redevelopment project in the Queen City. Honestly, redevelopment doesn’t begin to describe what the special tax zone (the Neighborhood Improvement Zone, NIZ for short) will mean for Allentown. The NIZ, created by a bill in the PA legislature, does things that make relocation to the NIZ very attractive. You can learn more about that here.
Something else the bill that created the NIZ does is return the Earned Income Tax of people who work in Allentown but don’t live there back to city to help fund the arena project. Some people don’t like that. Some, maybe most, local municipalities are used to using EITs to help fund the suburban school districts they support. Some people are starting to say “why should School District So and So pay for an Arena in Allentown?”
Those people miss the point.
For the last 47 years or so, Earned Income Tax in the Commonwealth has gone back to a worker’s home municipality instead of staying in the place where it was generated. Before 1965, this wasn’t the case. Before 1965 (read, before our core cities started failing), Earned Income Taxes stayed where they were made. Pennsylvania legislators, keen on seeing farmland turned to suburbs, put a stop to that and the townships blossomed with stripmalls, blacktop, and sprawl. Urban cores and urban schools were left to wither on the vine.
Look, I know it’s easy to get used to privilege, and then to expect it. But as Jon Geeting and others have been saying, the cost of living and doing business in the suburbs has been subsidized from the start. This isn’t about a hypothetically free market dictating that setting up shop in low-density townships made more sense than continuing to develop walkable cities. This is about, and always has been about, the myth of cheap suburban sprawl. Sprawl came at a cost to our economies, our infrastructure, our environment, and our mental and physical health. It came at a cost to our cities, to be sure, and to our schools.
No one is building an urban arena with money that should be going to buy football pads for rich school districts. No one is suggesting that we slash the budget of the Parkland High School closed-circuit television station so Spanish-speaking kids in Allentown can live in a city with a future. Who would ever suggest something like that?
Allow me to paraphrase one person who actually might. “Render onto Allentown what is Allentown’s.”
The Daily Cocca is proud to welcome Eric Sylvester back to our guest-blogger chair. Because all signs point to a proposed minor league hockey arena in downtown Allentown becoming the new home of the former Philadelphia Phantoms, I asked for Eric’s take on the team. Eric’s my go-to hockey guy, and with good reason.
Eric asked if he could write a piece about the 2004-2005 season, a time when big league hockey was locked out and a talented, neglected AHL team took the professional sport, and its near-professional fans across the country, on a wild, redemptive ride. Why is any of this important to me or to Allentown hockey in 2013? On a personal level, Eric’s a peach and I wanted him to a little bit about his beloved fandom. (He really did meet his girlfriend on WordPress, by the way, so you are beholding the power of blogging on two levels, here). But I’m also interested in the way sports narratives can galvanize communities. We’ve heard so much in the past few weeks about the kind of identify formation that happens at places like Penn State, but Eric was isolated hockey fan in Iowa who connected to a minor league team in South Philly. I don’t mean to overplay the sports-as-life narrative, because we’ve seen how devastating that can be. But in the right times and right conditions, fandom can bring communities together in positive ways, even across state lines and team loyalties.
Eric, thanks for the piece.
How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Phantoms by Eric Sylvester, Special (Like a Pretenders song) to The Daily Cocca
One of the best things about blogging is getting to hear the stories of a multitude of different types of people. I’ve made friends in the hockey community, the political ring, and some genuinely hilarious people through blogging. I even met my girlfriend, Emily, via this blog (that’s two shameless plugs for your blog already, babe). Editor’s Note: she smiled and DIDN’T hit me. I’m surprised, too. Editor’s Note #2: Upon reading this, she called me a “jerk” and hit me. THAT’S the Emily I know.
Chris Cocca is one of these great people I’ve had the pleasure of befriending since I started the blog. It’s always awesome when we get a chance to randomly talk, primarily because we share many of the same weird interests. From our mutual love for comics to our shared affinity for vintage baseball facial hair, we tend to have some interesting conversations.
I guest-posted last year during the NHL Playoffs for Cocca and have an undying love for hockey. So, naturally, when he started talking about the possibility of the Philadelphia Adirondack Phanotms AHL hockey team moving to Allentown (Chris’ hometown), I had a story to tell.
You see, the (then) Philadelphia Phantoms were the story of the 2005 hockey world. Why? Because the 2004-2005 NHL season was lost to a lockout. As the only hockey fan in my small hometown in Iowa, I was mercilessly teased by my friends. They knew how much hockey meant to me and reveled in the fact that they got to watch their beloved NBA while I was deprived of my favorite thing in the world. I look forward to hockey season more than Christmas, and that year Christmas wasn’t going to come.
But there was hockey in 2004-2005, just not the hockey I was used to following. The American Hockey League, America’s highest level of minor league hockey, would still play their season. With minor league hockey as my only option, I thought I was going to be subjected to a subpar league for a full season. Still, I said, bad puck is better than no puck at all. Mediocre players playing mediocre hockey in empty arenas is still hockey. I soldiered on and said my prayers to the hockey gods every night, begging for the return of the NHL.
I kept tabs on the affiliate of my Colorado Avalanche, the Hershey Bears, who never seemed destined for a playoff berth (they missed a postseason spot by ten points). My Colorado Avalanche didn’t exist and their affiliate franchise was done for the season . The most depressing year of my fifteen-year life lingered on. Even though there would be no proxy-Avalanche to lift my spirits in the playoffs, something else happened; something I wasn’t expecting.
I fell in love with the Philadelphia Phantoms. This wasn’t some throw-away hockey team playing in the minors. They had some SERIOUS firepower, and featured a bevy of future NHL superstars. Led by goaltender Antero Niittymaki (now with the San Jose Sharks), the Phantoms featured future NHL All-Star Jeff Carter, eventual Flyers’ captain Mike Richards, and future Stanley Cup winners Patrick Sharp and Ben Eager. The Phantoms grinded their way to the Calder Cup Finals with a style of play reminiscent of their big-brother Philadelphia Flyers of the mid 70’s: tight checking, strong defense, phenomenal goaltending, and (most of all) local fan support. When the Phantoms completed the surprising four game sweep of the Chicago Wolves to win the Calder Cup, 20,103 fans filled the Wachovia Center to witness the glory.
Yes, the Wachovia Center. The home of the Philadelphia Flyers. While my friends were busy mocking me for watching a league that “nobody” cared about, the Philadelphia Phantoms sold out an NHL arena.
Before the AHL playoffs, my frustration with a league that was shut down by greed (and at hockey-ignorant friends for taking so much pleasure in my misery) was hard. But I realized I wasn’t alone. The Phantoms became my retreat from a rural Iowa community that will never understand the connection hockey fans feel with each other, that hockey is as much of a culture as it is a sport. There’s a communal imperative, a bond among hockey fans that’s unique in sports. No matter who our teams are, we actively seek out each other’s company. As die-hard acolytes of a sport less mainstream, these days, than NASCAR or golf, we’re a rare breed in fandom. As much as we love the game, and we LOVE it, it’s simply one aspect of being a fan.
Deprived of an NHL to relate to, the lockout season started as especially difficult time in my life. While I was the only hockey fan in my school, I still could talk a little hockey with some of my sports-loving friends. One might catch the occasional game on ESPN (or at least see a highlight), and might seek me out with questions or for my brand of expert analysis. Hockey was, and is, so much a part of who I am that my classmates would rush to talk to me on a Monday simply because they had attended their first hockey game over the weekend. When the NHL season was lost I thought I’d lost my identity. I was no longer “the hockey guy”; I was the “guy who lost hockey.” As an angst-y fifteen-year-old, this was incredibly hard. And but for the Philadephia Adironack Allentown Phantoms, it would have stayed so.
In a year filled with pain and suffering for hockey fans across the world, I joined Philadelphia in embracing the Phantoms. I identified with them. The Philadelphia Phantoms were the minor league team in a city with an NHL team. The little brother. Mostly forgotten. They were the angst-y kid overlooked by the cute girls. Then, with the lockout, everyone knew me as the person most directly effected by the loss of a season and of a sport no one else cared much about in the small radius of our high school and town. In a strange way, the lockout didn’t take my identity at all; it bolstered my connection with something I thought I alone understood, and my reputation as someone with something at stake. That’s powerful esoteric sauce for kids figuring out who they are. (See: Cocca, Christopher; his love of Oasis). At the same time my identity formation was rising, the Phantoms went from Philadelphia’s forgotten team to the biggest story in hockey; among my friends and peers, I was the biggest story in hockey. The Phantoms were the greatest hockey team in the world, and I was the world’s biggest fan.
The Daily Cocca is happy to report that Eric is a well-adjusted college student preparing to lead our children into the 21st century as a teacher and weekly screener of Happy Gilmore. When the Phantoms come the Allentown, the local support Eric talked about will be crucial. So many of us have been rooting (and working) for downtown revitalization for so long, rooting for the Phantoms will require no adjustment. To the doubters or people less connected with the history of the city, we’ll need your help, too. Great things are already happening downtown. This could be a rallying and tipping point that helps foster a new stage of smart growth.